Traditional redistricting guidance presents five criteria for boundaries. 
The proposed boundaries favored by Commissioners Carollo, Reyes and Diaz de la Portilla violate three of those five criteria.

As applied to Coconut Grove, the proposed plan violates three of the five traditional redistricting criteria. See below and following slides.

  • Preserve communities of interest
    • Breaks up traditional Grove neighborhoods of Center, North and West Grove
    • Removes business district from (Center) Grove
  • Preserve core of prior districts
    • Divides three core districts of Coconut Grove: Center Grove, West Grove and North Grove
  • Use of man-made or natural boundaries
    • Ignores major road: US-1
    • Ignores the US-1 wall and I-95 in the North Grove
    • Ignores traditional boundary area of West Grove  

(His presentation is attached are found here: https://miami.nextrequest.com/documents/11546190/download )


Redistricting guidance.  https://miami.nextrequest.com/documents/11546190/download   11/18/21 Consultant DeGrandy presentation  to the Miami City Council. 

https://miami.nextrequest.com/requests/22-574

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

One Grove at US-1 Coconut Grove's Redistricting Threat

Image
  Miami's Commissioners  are changing the district boundaries of Coconut Grove. On 2/7/22 Commissioners Carollo, Reyes and Diaz de la Portilla directed changes to remove significant neighborhoods from the Grove's portion of district 2, shown above.   No action is required by law.  A vote of 3 of the 5 commissioners is sufficient to make a change. Most Grovites believe these changes are bad for all Grove residents.  The p roposed change: ·         divides historic unified neighborhoods and civic organizations ; ·         dilutes citizens' voice and votes; ·        is not now required by law; ·         reduces racial diversity in Coconut Grove's district; ·         all-but-severs the physical link between north and south Grove ; and ·         is being rushed by city commis...
Read more

Dividing the Grove: A three-way split.

Image
Mayor Suarez failed to save Coconut Grove.  See the Miami Herald's editorial  https://www.miamiherald.com/opinion/editorials/article260170340.html  and other's insights  https://www.politicalcortadito.com/2022/04/05/no-veto-miami-redistricting/   One Grove, however, continues to support neighborhoods trying to preserve their representation. Natoma Manors HOA and Grove Park are meeting to pursue relief. The NAACP and ACLU are mobilizing to reverse the transfer to Reyes. Separate pleadings to the county's and state's ethics boards are in process. Legal suits are in draft and coordination. More stuff too, that we don't talk about. This now-long campaign requires sustained resources to support experts, analyses, legal proceedings and keeping neighbors informed.  Your fundraising support is needed now. GoFundMe.com/KeepCoconutGroveTogether .  Not shown on that website are the significant contributions made directly to One Grove's legal fund.  Taken to...
Read more

Possible revisions to proposed district boundaries

City officials have indicated that a revision the the redistricting proposal is possible. As of this writing, a revised plan has not been seen by One Grove members. One Grove is eager to receive and study the revision. A revision demonstrates the truth of One Grove’s claim that ‘Other, better options are possible.’ There is no requirement for Miami to rush through a redistricting plan. Therefore, if and when One Grove receives any revision or proposal, we will: -- distribute it to citizens and civic groups,  -- analyze the proposal and its potential effects, -- discuss the proposal carefully with stakeholders city-wide and -- form a balanced recommendation for our elected officials.  We ask of others the same consideration for ourselves and those less able to speak out. We anticipate that a revision will be presented at City Hall, 12:00 Friday 2/25. Commissioner Russell has scheduled a public meeting to discuss the plan for next Monday 2/28 and we look...
Read more